Find me spot logo

4/6/2009

 

The Spot messenger is a personal satellite locator. It's a relatively simple device that doesn't rely on cellular towers for sending messages. The device has four buttons: On/off, Ok, Help and 911, like I said, simple. The basic level of service allows you to push the Ok button to send a message to a distribution list you've created with GPS coordinates and a brief note that everything is alright. The Help button sends GPS coordinates a message to the distribution list requesting that someone send assistance (not an emergency, you just want some help). The 911 button alerts emergency services with your location and a request for emergency assistance.

When you register the device, you can also upgrade services to include additional global search and rescue insurance (at a very reasonable annual cost) and to provide a web based tracking service that will update a web page with your location every 10 minutes while the device is turned on.

I learned about the device when my friend Adrian Stingaciu did the Tour Divide mountain bike race (starts in Canada near the US/Canadian border and goes to the US / Mexico border -- over 2,000 miles of mountain bike racing! Ouch!). I became a daily addict watching the racers progress across the country. Someone on the route did use the 911 feature once to get emergency support for a car accident that happened on a remote part of the route. Strange how fun it is to watch little dots moving across a google map.

Annette also liked the concept, so we debated about getting a spot messenger for my long distance rides. Then Costco started selling them right around Christmas last year. It included the device and one year of basic service. We thought it would be a good investment and would help with peace of mind, so I bought one before the Casa Grande Century in January. And I bought the additional insurance and web tracking update service...might as well get the full package! Unfortunately, my initial experience with web tracking wasn't stellar. I put the device in a jersey pocket and it seemed to work for the first 10 or 15 miles, then it stopped updating the webpage. I contacted Spot technical support after the ride and they said it appeared the device couldn't find satellites. Hmmmm.... I tried it again on a 200k brevet later in the month and had a similar problem. So I searched the web for potential answers.

Turns out the Spot Messenger has a "patch" antennae located under the spot logo on the device. To get a good satellite signal that logo needs to have an unobstructed view of the sky. So on those initial rides, I had the spot in my back jersey pocket, but when it warmed up, I stuffed arm warmers and leg warmers back there too and probably blocked the signal. Lesson learned! For the 300k, I used a detours trunk and secured the Spot messenger to the top. It now had a clear, unobstructed view of the sky for the entire ride ... and it worked perfectly! The web page updated every 10 minutes as advertised! On rides where I didn't have the detours trunk, I attached the spot to the back of my seat bag. It wasn't pointed up, but it wasn't obstructed either. That worked ok until Mine Country Challenge last weekend. Then the device worked consistently for about 1/2 of the ride before it stopped sending updates. I was riding next to a pretty big cliff, so the terrain could have been obstructing it initially, but later I was riding through open range and it still didn't update (of course, since there's no error indicators on the device, I had no idea there was a problem). Near the end of the ride updates started occurring again.

Battery life in the device is supposed to be 14 days, but I don't know if that includes sending web updates every 10 minutes. It could be that I used up the first set of batteries. It hasn't been close to 14 days of continuous use, but it's probably close to 72 hours of web updating. I swapped the batteries for the MS Bike Round Up, but continue to have spotty web updates.  It may be that the device is hanging vertically off the saddle bag, so the logo isn't facing up.  I'll have to figure out a way to get that logo pointed up.  The device has a belt clip so it is intended to hang vertically, so I'm surprised it has such problems when the logo isn't directly up.

So, what's the verdict? Is the device worth the $150+/year fee? The device is far from perfect and really needs some improvements (especially with the consistency of the web updates), but it is ABSOLUTELY worth the investment! It's unobtrusive for me and my family LOVES seeing where I am during a ride, even if it isn't at the advertised 10 minute per web update rate. When the device stops sending updates for a significant amount of time (~an hour), Annette tries to call, so I want it to work consistently, but just giving them some peace of mind and security in knowing where I am and that I can always push that "help" button is just great.

Here's my wish list for the next generation messenger:

- a battery life scale/bar indicator. I'd like to know how much juice is left before I go on an adventure so I can change batteries if needed
- the option for an external, stronger antennae. I always want a satellite signal, even if it means I may have to change batteries a bit more frequently (and that battery indicator would help tell me that)
- an "error" indicator that stays on if more than one or two message transmission attempts is unsuccessful so I know when my family isn't seeing updates
- a smaller form factor (yeah, I'm asking for nirvana). Work with Garmin! I have a Garmin 405 wristwatch GPS that gets a signal INDOORS! If Garmin can do that with such a small device, surely there's hope of getting a smaller Spot.
- Rechargeable, built in li-po batteries with a mini-USB charging port. There are MANY portable mini-USB battery chargers out there. I use an Energizer Energi-to-go and an APC charging device for my Garmin 705 that both work perfectly and I always have them on long events.
- A "friendly" URL for Spot updates... something like findmespot.com/enfield or findmespot.com/track/enfield

If the folks at Find Me Spot deliver these, I'll be one of the first to upgrade my device!

     

Copyright © 2009 by Mike Enfield. All rights reserved.
Revised: 09/16/13 12:59:27 -0600.